By HarvardHomemaker

I'm a Harvard graduate and homemaker who blogs about living (and loving!) the domestic life with my husband and four young daughters. My blog now permanently resides at www.harvardhomemaker.com. Please visit me there!

Posted on Saturday, October 6, 2012 at 11:16:00 PM in Recipes
Tags: baking,  healthy,  greek yogurt,  applesauce,  baking tip,  tip,  pumpkin,  bar,  fall,  halloween

Moist & Healthy Pumpkin Bars - Made with Applesauce

If you love pumpkin bars, look no further--this recipe is for you!  My aunt gave me the original recipe, and then I modified it.  I took out an entire CUP of oil, and I also replaced the four eggs it called for with egg beaters.  You will never know the difference--I promise.  

At Thanksgiving one year, my aunt and I actually both brought these to share--although she had used the original recipe, and I had used this healthier version.  Everyone (even my aunt!) agreed that the modified recipe was the winner, hands-down!  You will not believe how moist these are... give them a try!

Start by mixing together the egg beaters, sugar, applesauce, and pumpkin.  Beat well.

Next mix in all the dry ingredients.  Typically recipes ask you to mix these separately in another bowl and then add them to the wet ingredients.  That means I'd have to wash another bowl, and that's just crazy talk.  I usually put the dry ingredients right in with the wet ones and stir things up a bit by hand before I start with the mixer.  The end result always seems the same to me whether or not I mix the dry ingredients first in a separate bowl.  So I usually skip that step.

Mix well for about 2-3 minutes and pour into a large pan with sides.  I use an insulated pan that is approximately 15x10.

When I bake, I find that I have much better luck with insulated pans.  They are made with double layers of metal with air between them.  This allows the heat to move evenly throughout the pan before it moves to the food--this eliminates hots spots and results in more even cooking.  (I find it especially important to use insulated pans when baking cookies.)  If you look closely in the photo below, you can see how the pan is thicker than typical metal baking pans.

Bake at 350 in a preheated oven for approximately 25 minutes.  Remove from the oven when the center bounces back up when you touch it lightly.  Also, if you jiggle the pan a bit, the mixture shouldn't move.  If it's still shaking in the middle, it's probably not quite done.

As bars are cooling, you can mix up the frosting.  * Careful not to over-mix!  My husband and kids made these once for my birthday, and the frosting came out very runny.  Never one to "under-do" anything, my husband beat the crap out of that frosting and managed to bring the butter back to its liquid state!  When you over-mix, the butter begins to separate--basically, it's melting.  You don't want that.

Frost bars once they are completely cool.  I do store the bars in the fridge because otherwise the frosting seems to "melt" after a while.  If you think you will be eating these within about 24 hours and don't want cold bars, you can store them at room temperature.  And let's be honest, usually these don't last 24 hours!

Over 10,000 costumes and accessories from HalloweenMart

Click here for a printer-friendly version of the recipe below.


1 cup egg beaters (the equivalent of 4 eggs)

1 2/3 cup sugar

1 cup applesauce (I usually use 2 small containers that I always have on hand for my kids' lunches... probably just shy of 1 cup but close enough!)

2 cups pumpkin (I use one 15 oz. can... probably just over 2 cups, but again--close enough!)

2 cups flour

2 t. baking powder

2 t. baking soda

2 t. cinnamon

1 t. salt


5 oz. 1/3 fat cream cheese, softened (leave out of fridge for a while)

1/2 cup butter, softened (leave this out of fridge for a bit, too)

1 tsp. vanilla

2 cups powdered sugar


Preheat oven to 350 and remove cream cheese and butter from the fridge so they can begin to soften.  Mix together egg beaters, sugar, applesauce, and pumpkin.  Beat well.  Add flour, baking powder, baking soda, cinnamon, and salt.  Stir by hand for a bit to mix in dry ingredients and then beat well for about 2-3 minutes.  Pour into baking sheet with sides--my pan is about 15x10.  * I recommend using an insulated pan if you have one.  (I do lightly spray the baking sheet with Pam, but I'm not sure if this step is truly necessary... I've just always been afraid to skip it!)  Bake for about 25 minutes or until the center springs back a bit when you touch it lightly.  (You can also test for doneness with a toothpick--it should come out clean.)  

Mix all ingredients together for the frosting.  * Careful not to over-mix or the butter will separate and the frosting will be runny.  Spread evenly over bars.  Store bars in the refrigerator if you will not be eating them all within about 24 hours.

I hope these became a fall favorite in your house!  Let me know how it goes!

What recipes have you successfully modified?  Please share your ideas!

Until next time, 

Love vs Design Birth Announcements


You may also like:

Top 10 Parenting Tips of 2013 by Harvard Homemaker

As 2013 comes to a close, I have been reflecting back on what posts and ideas generated the most interest over the last year.  This is the first of several posts I'll share to sum up Harvard

Dec 27 2013, 07:49 PM - 2244 Views - 0 comments

Famous Healthy 15-Minute Tortellini Soup

Alright, my friends, this is a recipe you're going to want to try!  If you like tortellini, and you like soup (and you like FAST!), this one is for you!!  My friends and family can't

Feb 20 2013, 11:26 PM - 4757 Views - 6 comments

Hearty Slow Cooker Chicken Noodle Soup

This is the best chicken noodle soup ever.  Yes, ever.  (My husband says that sometimes I'm too enthusiastic and then things can never live up to the hype--but for the record, I really

Oct 24 2012, 12:57 AM - 20173 Views - 8 comments

Healthier Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Bread (So Good!)

People, I'm telling you, this stuff is good.  Seriously, if you like pumpkin bread, you have to try this!  I have modified the original recipe by cutting out half the oil and replacing it

Sep 30 2013, 02:42 PM - 1360 Views - 0 comments

Easy No-Sew DIY Minion Costumes

This Halloween costume idea is simply genius.  I can say that because I didn't come up with it; my super-creative friend did!  Last fall, two of my daughters and a few of their friends all

Sep 22 2013, 01:55 PM - 9883 Views - 0 comments

Tart & Sweet Cranberry Applesauce

The cranberry part of Thanksgiving used to gross me out.  But thanks to this cranberry applesauce recipe, it's my favorite part of the meal now!  And I don't even like cranberries!!

Nov 13 2012, 02:31 PM - 2146 Views - 2 comments

Two Ingredient Sweet Apple Dip

Short on time and looking for the easiest (but still impressive!) fall appetizer?  This simple recipe (if you can even call it that) is a go-to for me this time of year.  My dear friend

Nov 7 2012, 05:44 PM - 2823 Views - 0 comments

Share the Halloween Spirit by "Boo-ing" Your Neighbors

I had never heard of "Boo-ing" until I moved south.  It's not something we did growing up.  But boy, would I have loved it!!  It is right up my alley.  Well, the apple doesn't

Oct 7 2012, 06:26 PM - 2397 Views - 3 comments

Quick First Day of School Pictures: Use Fingers to Show New Grade

The first day of school is such an exciting time--it's a fresh start and the beginning of a new adventure. But it's also a very hectic time!  My kids are actually in year-round school here,

Jul 17 2013, 11:34 AM - 3313 Views - 0 comments

Multiplying by 9 Trick

Many of you probably know about today's tip, but if this is one you have never seen before, buckle your seatbelt!!  You're going to wish you'd had this trick in your back pocket when learning

Mar 29 2013, 09:17 PM - 3658 Views - 0 comments

10 Things to Think About Before Your Child Starts Kindergarten (That Have Nothing to Do With Academics)

Is your child starting kindergarten soon?  As a mother who has now sent three children off to kindergarten (with one more to go), I know that can be an emotional period of transition for the

Jul 25 2013, 03:29 PM - 75257 Views - 4 comments

100 Books for All Ages: Gifts Galore!

We love books.  As you can tell by the picture above, they get a lot of love in our house.  I think books make the best gifts, especially when you have no idea what to get someone.  I

Nov 17 2012, 08:43 PM - 8166 Views - 14 comments


Add comment

Signin or Signup to comment